Hydraulic Lifters vs. Solid Mechanical Lifters in Classic Cars

Hydraulic lifters are an essential part of restoring or maintaining classic cars. Among the hydraulic lifters, small components have an important role in intake and exhaust valve operation. 

The topic of hydraulic versus solid lifters bring a lot of discussions to the table. Each has unique benefits and drawbacks, offering a great difference in driving experience and longevity for classic cars.

In this article, we discuss the differences between hydraulic and solid lifters, maintenance practices, and replacement processes.  We will also discuss how these components contribute to the performance of an engine and which type might be better for your classic car restoration project.

What Are Hydraulic Lifters?

Hydraulic lifters are components in the internal combustion engine designed to automatically regulate valve clearance through means of oil pressure in order to keep the valves running quietly and smoothly . 

These lifters work by filling up with engine oil and, through this pressure, push a small piston inside the lifter to eliminate any gaps between the camshaft and the valve train. These steps result in smoother valve timing while eliminating frequent manual adjustments.

What are Solid Lifters?

In other words, solid lifters, also known as mechanical lifters, do not feature this self-adjusting trait. They require periodic manual adjustments to maintain ideal clearance between the camshaft and the valve train. Hydraulic lifters are normally favored for their ability to allow quieter operation of an engine and less maintenance of classic cars because parts are much more susceptible to wear and tear.

How to Differentiate Between Hydraulic and Solid Lifters

Knowing whether an engine has hydraulic or solid lifters can be important when maintaining or restoring a classic car. The following steps will help you determine what your engine has in just a few steps:

• Check the Build Sheet: A build sheet of your car contains the original specifications of your car’s engine, including the type of lifters it had. If you can’t find the build sheet, you can get a copy of the classic car build sheet online.
• Listen for Noise: Hydraulic lifters eliminate most noise in an engine. If your engine is making more of a pronounced tapping, especially cold, you have a solid lifter that depends upon periodic adjustment to maintain proper valve clearance.
• Rocker Arms Inspection: The valve cover needs to be taken off in order to observe the rocker arms and the lifter. A hydraulic lifter engine will normally feature a little plunger inside that you can push in by hand, but a solid lifter is rigid and doesn’t compress. 
• Engine Behavior: Hydraulic lifters tend to provide a smoother-running engine at idle and quieter in their operation. Engines fitted with solid lifters may run slightly rougher, more especially at idle, due to the tighter valve lash and the fact that adjustment is required manually.
• Consult a Mechanic: If you are not sure and don’t want to take a look yourself, the good idea will be to take the advice of a classic car mechanic who can tell you what kind of lifters are installed and what is foreseen from a maintenance or upgrade point of view.

Related: Iconic Great Cars With Pop-Up Headlights

The Pros and Cons of Hydraulic Roller Lifters in Classic Cars

However desirable, hydraulic lifters certainly have their serious drawbacks. Let’s look at some of the pros and cons associated with hydraulic lifters in classic cars.

Advantages

• Less Maintenance: The hydraulic lifters self-adjust, eliminating the regular valve clearance adjustments when one uses solid lifters.
• Smoother Operation: Hydraulic lifters tend to make the operation quieter because of their self-adjusting nature; this becomes more evident in classic cars, which have a little loud noise from the engine.
• Long Life: With hydraulic lifters maintaining proper valve timing, they can reduce wear and tear on other engine parts, thereby allowing the engine to operate longer.

Disadvantages

• Oil Quality Sensitivity: Hydraulic lifters rely on clean engine oil to function correctly. Low-quality oil, or not changing the oil often enough, can cause malfunction or failure of a hydraulic lifter.
• Noisy: Normally quiet, hydraulic lifters can become noisy if not properly maintained – or if air feeding into the lifter from low oil pressure occurs.

Hydraulic Lifter Replacement in a Classic Car

Hydraulic lifter replacement in a classic car demands precision and the right tool. To perform the replacement job, in this article, we shall be considering how to do it with the following steps:

1. Gather Tools and Materials: The materials and tools needed are a torque wrench, socket set, new hydraulic lifters, engine oil, and a clean work area.
2. Pull off the Valve Cover: First, pull off the valve cover so you can visualize the lifter. Disconnect all accessories or components that may interfere with your cover.
3. Pull off the Rocker Arms: Loosen all the rocker arms sitting atop the lifter. This allows the lifter to be pulled out freely.
4. Hydraulic Lifter Removal: Gently pull the old hydraulic lifters out of their slots by using a lifter removal tool. While the lifter is out, make sure that the cam shaft lobes are checked for wear.
5. Install New Lifter: Place a new lifter into the engine, ensuring proper seating. Dip the lifter in clean oil before installation. Place the rocker arms and torque to specs, then replace the valve cover.

Before you start a replacement, check the classic car build sheet to see if the lifters you install meet your car’s original specifications. By doing so, you will be sure you’re restoring your engine to its original form and performance maintenance, as well as its value.

Related: Best Classic Muscle Cars of All Time

Hydraulic Lifter Maintenance Tips

The hydraulic lifters need regular maintenance so that your classic car engine’s performance and longevity are retained. Here are some practical tips:

• Regular Oil Changes: Hydraulic lifters depend on oil for performance, so changing the oil frequently is required. It is best to use top-quality oil to avoid building up and to ensure smooth performance.
• Wear Check: No unusual ticking or tapping noise should emerge from the engine. These could be symptoms of the lifter starting to wear out or being unable to hold their oil pressure.
• OiI Viscosity: Using the wrong viscosity of oil in the engine, whether very thick or too thin, will impede the right adjustment of the lifter.

If you’re in the market to buy a classic car and want to be certain it has been well maintained according to the factory’s maintenance schedule, obtain the classic vehicle history report to track maintenance.

Hydraulic vs. Solid Lifters: Which is Better for Your Classic Car?

Choosing a hydraulic or solid lift engine will depend a lot on driving habits and the intended use of a classic car.

• Hydraulic Lifter: A hydraulic lifter may be your better choice if you want a quieter, low-maintenance, smooth-running engine. Hydraulic lifters are ideal for daily driving and for people who do not want a lot of maintenance responsibility.
• Solid Lifter: Solid lifters are a lot more for high-performance driving. For classic cars that you know will go through racing or other demanding driving, solid lifters give you better control over valve timing, and they are generally much better for highly revving engines. 

It depends on your driving style and how often you want to put into maintaining your car.

Related: Best Popular Cars of the 1960s: Greatest Car Makes and Models in the 60s

Conclusion

If you’re working on classic cars, it’s important to know whether you have a hydraulic or solid roller lifter. Hydraulic lifters operate much smoother, are quieter, and require less maintenance, while solid lifters are best suited for high-performance usages. Being able to identify the type of lifter present in your engine and perform the proper maintenance on it will ensure that the classic car runs without serious issues for many years.

Frequently Asked Questions